Jingdezhen Ru Porcelain vs Ruzhou Ru Porcelain: A Guide to Choosing Between Tradition and Innovation

In the realm of Chinese ceramic art, Ru porcelain stands out for its jade-like glaze and understated elegance, making it a coveted treasure among collectors throughout history. However, in today's market, Ru porcelain is primarily divided into two major schools—Ruzhou Ru porcelain (the original) and Jingdezhen Ru porcelain (a modern revival). While both share the same roots, they differ significantly in craftsmanship, aesthetics, and market positioning.  

This article will explore their historical backgrounds, technical characteristics, artistic styles, and collectible value to help you make an informed choice when purchasing.  

---

I. Historical Origins: Orthodox Heritage vs. Contemporary Innovation 

1. Ruzhou Ru Porcelain: The Millennial Echo of Northern Song Official Kiln. 
-The Only Official Kiln Site: The Qingliangsi kiln site in Ruzhou has been confirmed as the sole official kiln of Song Dynasty Ru ware, with fewer than 100 authentic pieces surviving—truly a "legend among ceramics."  
-Lost and Revived: The original Ru ware techniques were lost after the Southern Song Dynasty and were only partially restored through archaeological discoveries in the late 20th century. Today, production remains largely tied to intangible cultural heritage preservation.  
-Key Features: Strict adherence to ancient methods, using locally sourced clay and agate glaze, along with the traditional "spur-mark firing" technique, to replicate the Song Dynasty standards.  

2. Jingdezhen Ru Porcelain: A Modern Interpretation of Tradition  
-Non-Original Revival: Leveraging a thousand years of porcelain-making expertise, Jingdezhen, in collaboration with the Palace Museum, has revived Ru porcelain using modern technology—though it is not the historical origin.  
-Innovations: While preserving Ru ware’s aesthetic essence, advancements like electric kiln temperature control and 3D body molding have boosted success rates (from 10% traditionally to over 60%).  
-Market Positioning: Focuses on practicality and contemporary aesthetics, such as tea sets and decorative art pieces.  

---

II. Craftsmanship Comparison: Spur-Mark Firing vs. Ring-Foot Firing

1. Ruzhou Ru Porcelain: The Ultimate Aesthetic of Spur-Mark Firing
-Technique: Uses 3-5 sesame-seed-sized spurs to support the ware during firing, resulting in a fully glazed body with only tiny spur marks—a hallmark of Song imperial standards.  
-Advantages: The glaze remains intact, offering a smooth, luxurious feel and higher collectible value.  
-Limitations: Suitable only for small pieces, with low yield rates (~30%) and high prices (starting at hundreds of USD).  

2. Jingdezhen Ru Porcelain: The Pragmatism of Ring-Foot Firing  
- Technique: Adopts Jingdezhen’s traditional ring-foot firing, where the base is left unglazed for stability, making it ideal for mass production.  
- Advantages: Higher yield rates (over 70%), ability to produce larger items (e.g., vases, teapots), and more accessible pricing.
- Limitations: The unglazed base is wider, sacrificing the "fully glazed" perfection; some pieces mimic spur marks for a traditional touch.  

Ru Porcelain with Nail-Support Technique from Ru Zhou

---

III. Artistic Style: Subtle Elegance vs. Diverse Innovation  

Aspect	Ruzhou Ru Porcelain	Jingdezhen Ru Porcelain
Glaze Color	Dominated by celadon, matte finish, subdued tones	Celadon, powder-blue, pea-green, slightly more lustrous
Crackle	Natural "cicada-wing" or "fish-roe" patterns	Controlled ice-crack or crab-claw patterns, some artificially induced
Forms	Strictly Song-style (triple-legged zun, lotus bowls)	Blends modern designs (tea sets, artistic wares)

---

IV. How to Choose? Collecting vs. Practical Use  

Choose Ruzhou Ru Porcelain if:  
✅ You seek the "authentic" Song Dynasty Ru ware and value historical significance  
✅ Your budget allows for spur-mark firing’s premium craftsmanship and rarity  
✅ Intended for collection or as a high-end gift  

Choose Jingdezhen Ru Porcelain if: 
✅ You prioritize practicality and affordability for daily use (e.g., tea sets)  
✅ You prefer contemporary designs that integrate Ru aesthetics into modern life  
✅ Your budget is limited but you still wish to experience Ru ware’s beauty  

Ru Porcelain Without Nail-Support Technique from Jingdezhen

---

V. Market Insights & Buying Tips
- Ruzhou Ru Porcelain: Mainly produced by heritage artisans (e.g., Zhu Wenli, Wang Junzi), prices are steep—look for the "Ruzhou Geographical Indication" label.  
- Jingdezhen Ru Porcelain: Offers a wider range, from affordable tea sets to high-end art pieces; seek studios with patented revival techniques.  

---

Tradition and Innovation, Each with Its Merits
Ruzhou Ru porcelain is a "living fossil of history," embodying the pinnacle of Song Dynasty aesthetics, while Jingdezhen Ru porcelain represents "tradition reimagined," bringing Ru ware into modern living spaces.  

For collectors and purists, Ruzhou Ru ware is the only choice. For those valuing functionality and innovation, Jingdezhen Ru porcelain may be the better fit.  

Regardless of your choice, the serene elegance of Ru porcelain will continue to endure, narrating the timeless allure of Chinese ceramics.